B.Sudhakar Shenoy
Amazon.in18 Apr 2026
Lawyers Vs Engineers at the helm
This is an extremely well researched, insightful and timely book in a world where China emerges as an economic and military superpower in a multi polar world. The young author, with excellent academic credentials, has the unique advantage of having spent several years in both China and USA, thus providing an unbiased and multifaceted view of the land and the people. Outlining the economic, social and technological trajectories, with primary focus on China he draws parallels and highlights contrasts between China and America on key points. The chapter ‘Engineers Vs Lawyers’ sets out to compare present day China with USA in the later half of the nineteenth century, that saw an gilded age of economic expansion, the rise of mega industries, highways and manufacturing capabilities. There was much to be done and money to be made, giving rise to the infamous robber barons and the negative externality that impacted the environment and society in equal measure. As a means to fight against this, lawyers emerged as a profession, in white armor, and with a furious rigor to litigate and legislate. Today, USA has over 400 lawyers per one hundred thousand population, perhaps the highest in the world. Lawyers do what they do best: litigate, and block. Thus, the profession has now become a major barrier to building America, that is lost in a labyrinth of laws that are self-defeating and a system that chases procedures and forgets the outcome. The result is obvious. America’s infrastructure is archaic and crumbling. Its manufacturing capability is outsourced. Its universities lack funding. America has lost its preeminent position on this planet. China on the other hand is managed by qualified engineers. As a matter of fact, all top leaders and ministers including President Xi Jinping are engineers, and are elevated to higher positions, only after a proven track record of having managed multi-billion-dollar projects. Engineers do what they do best: Build. China’s capability to build, and manufacture on a scale that surpasses our imagination many times over, is not communist propaganda, as brushed aside by some. Take the high-speed train example. Launched in 2008, a 800-mile Beijing-Shanghai stretch was opened in 2011 at a cost of $36 billion. Within a decade, it completed 1.35 billion passenger trips, safely. The California’s rail line began construction in 2008. Till date, nowhere near completion, it has a revised cost of $128 billion, and estimated to be functional between 2030 and 2033. Shanghai moved more containers in 2022 than all US ports combined. From 2018 to 2019, China produced 4.4 billion tons of cement, that is close to the entire amount of cement produced by USA in one the twentieth century. Interestingly, China is more capitalistic than USA in some aspects. Business friendly, extremely flexible business laws and low taxation. But then, the book quickly changes to the human side of China. For a state that is managed by engineers, human beings are merely an input into the manufacturing process. People are controlled like any other raw material. The chapters ‘One Child’ and ‘Zero Covid’ narrate the most disturbing part of China, and I found it very hard to read. I teared up while reading some pages. The final question in this book is to find ways and means of human progress with human rights as guaranteed and celebrated in USA, and to build the nation with the efficiency and scale of China. That would be a reality that we might see soon, in a multi-polar world order, that respects all nations as equals, and with humanity at its core. This is the most invaluable book that I have read in the last decade. An excellent guide to all nations to learn, reflect and thrive. God bless you Dan. Read more Read less









