Makes the history of Irish immigrants to America come to life
Like most people I knew a little about the many Irish people who emigrated to the US to look for a better future but this film adds a face and a story. It has sweetness and depth and credibility. I like the clothes too. Will be watching it again a few times Read more Read less
F
FictionFan
Amazon.in
24 Nov 2016
★★★★★Verified purchase
A great film and more faithful to the book than most adaptations...
This is a wonderful film that gets Tóibín’s quiet emotionalism and gentle humour perfectly. The acting is brilliant all round and Saoirse Ronan’s central performance as Eilis Lacey thoroughly deserves all the awards nominations it has received. It’s beautifully filmed. Although I understand most of the Brooklyn scenes were actually shot in Canada, they nonetheless feel entirely authentic, but the Ireland scenes are fabulous, showing to full effect the gorgeous scenery and lush greenness of the Emerald Isle. It’s a special treat that some of the scenes are shot in Toibin’s own birthplace of Enniscorthy, the place where so many of his novels are set. Although the film sticks very closely to the plot of the novel, for me there were some significant differences in emphasis that somewhat changed what I thought of as the central themes. For example, in the book, Eilis has brothers who don't get mentioned in the film – this made her mother seem much more isolated and alone than in the book, where she comes over as somewhat more selfish. Also Eilis is less passive in the film than in the book, and her love affair has a slightly different emphasis. (Forgive the vagueness - trying hard to avoid spoilers.) However, the differences are subtle, of tone rather than of story and, as always, come down to a matter of personal interpretation, and the different requirements of the film format. Overall it's more faithful to the book than most film adaptations and, taking it simply as a film, it's hugely enjoyable. Highly recommended. Read more Read less
"
"Bella"
Amazon.in
19 Mar 2024
★★★★★Verified purchase
Heartfelt and deep... maybe too deep
The highlight of the movie for me was the 2 "giddy girls" at the dinner table. Splash! Priceless girly humor that had me smiling. Overall good movie but it could have been great and even if it didn't have a couple of scenes that were a bit raw. There is one scene where it shows somebody drop dead and the immense pain that is captured is intense to say the least. Too much for the young or emotionally fragile. Speaking of that, there is one scene of the young couple in the bedroom. I don't think this was really necessary for the story and now I don't want to share it with my young niece anymore. It's so hard to find clean and virtuous movies today and you really have to search. (Anne of Green Gables style movies are few and far between) The lead actress is also in another movie "Little Women" that is family friendly and therefore gets 5 stars. So I prefer that movie to this one. Still glad I have this for my collection though. Important warning: Before you order a copy of this movie, find out and ensure you are ordering the correct regional code. I actually watched this movie on Netflix and You tube and ordered a DVD copy that didn't play in my player (regional code) I've contacted the seller about this b/c it was not indicated. Buyer beware with used movies! Hopefully they will be able to get me a copy that plays here or give me a refund. Read more Read less
C
C.Befus
Amazon.in
30 Jul 2026
★★★★★Verified purchase
One of my favorite movies
Arrived very quickly. Read more Read less
O
oh Kinsley
Amazon.in
4 May 2024
★★★★★Verified purchase
Does not play on our Canadian DVD player . Very disappointed!!!!
Should of said doesn't play on Canada or US DVD's Not happy Read more Read less
P
Prachi Rai
Amazon.in
14 Sept 2016
★★★★★
slow and a beautiful movie. I liked it
calm,serene,slow and a beautiful movie.I liked it. Read more Read less