This is probably the BEST book for anyone who needs help processing through "what just happened" after a bad church experience. Robby is EXTREMELY helpful and pastoral and thoughtful and.... as a pastor I recommend this book to everyone I know who gets burned or frustrated, etc. In fact, I know a few people that need to read it... Read more Read less
T
The Torpedo
Amazon.in
22 Sept 2012
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
Misery loves company...especially if you're a crab.
Sometimes in my own period of church detox, I've wondered if anyone else was going through the same misgivings and anguish of leaving institutional church. (Mr. McAlpine shies away from the use of the term "institutional church", but I prefer it, as it alludes to the commonly established structure church has become in America.) After 30 years of involvement in institutional churches, I not only realized the inherent flaws in the system, but considered that there must be a better way. This book both confirms my suspicions and gives me hope about the nature of misery in leaving, and in knowing I'm not the only one to experience it. Leaving for me was easy and simple compared to dealing with the after effects, and his book makes clear some of those issues. His statement, "we need to recognize that our spiritual growth and maturity is not the responsibility of the church" is one of the more profound in the book, even though it seems self apparent . Institutional church, in my experience, represents a la carte Christianity. Institutional churches cater to satisfying felt needs and disseminating doctrine, and larger institutional churches do it particularly well. Essentially, leaders do the yeoman's work, and the people enjoy the benefits. It's a kind of co-dependency with institutional church. However, something institutional church can't offer on the menu is the kind of maturation or growth that takes place when individuals study the Bible, serve their fellow man/woman or worship God for themselves under the auspice of the Holy Spirit. Unfortunately, it probably took me longer than it should have to realize that personal responsibility. It was after leaving institutional church that the regret and misgivings about my participation became apparent. Another of his somewhat disconcerting statements was, "If you knew what you know now, before joining this church, would you have still joined it? If the answer is a clear 'NO', why are you staying?" I can well identify with this. For years my wife and I asked of ourselves similarly only to keep going back. In the end, we could no longer endure the inner charade. The emotional baggage was too much to continue to bear. In the author's chapter called "Sheep Bit" he has a particularly intriguing concept called "The List of Flaws". The "List" is figuratively assembled by leadership to lend credence to the prospect of getting rid of those they deem expendable. In my case, this "List" wasn't telegraphed in an obvious way, but looking back on the events and encounters of the past it was apparent that an imaginable "Short List" of excuses was in mind. Troublesome excuses existed to diminish my contribution and put me into an expendable category as a congregant. Mr. McAlpine's advice in this chapter is well taken. It's not the particulars on the "List" someone would appeal to if someone should find themselves the object, it's the fact that a "List" exists at all. Appealing to scripture, particularly Matthew 18 as was mentioned, is a fruitless hope, to which I can personally attest. Overall the book is a quick read, and very helpful. His perspective is from the view point of a former pastor, however it is insightful for any congregant, particularly those in lay church leadership. The struggle to detox from church is so because bitterness is "...crouching at the door, and its desire..." (Genesis 4:7) is for the Christian. McAlpine's final exhortation, "guard your hearts", is fraught with sober warning from experience. Read more Read less
L
L. N. Oar
Amazon.in
3 Mar 2013
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Church Pains
The condition of organized “church” is often lamented because it often is lamentable. This book is for anyone who has ever felt misunderstood or even betrayed by “the system”. Sometimes church can wound the very people it is meant to help. Robby McAlpine writes mainly from the position of clergy, but what he writes about could be the experience of any involved church person. There are many Christians with church inflicted pain who limp through life because their efforts have been belittled or written off as being without value or worse. Sometimes it would seem their enemies are from amongst the very people they have admired and respected the most. According to the author, “ There are some things we simply have no control over. But we can ...deal with the things we can change. ...those changes will almost always begin with us.” Definitely, hurting Christians can help solve this problem. McAlpine's words need to be heeded if wounded Christians are to move on. He presents a choice: to become “bitter hamsters furiously spinning on a treadmill of resentment” or to forgive, give up resentment, and from that day forward go on to spiritual growth and maturity. Read more Read less
H
Hasaan
Amazon.in
30 Jun 2021
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
Just what I needed
Thought provoking and so many areas hit right where my heart currently is. Helping me through a valley and has encouraged me to keep going. Read more Read less