Srinivas Kirthy K
Amazon.in3 Dec 2020
A good student atlas for the price with scope for improvement
Here is my critical review of the 3rd edition (2019) of the Oxford Student Atlas for India. Positives: 1. Content: a) The publishers have used recent Indian and international data sources (2011-2018), making the maps up-to-date. b) The spellings of the names of the places have been updated (I was able to check this for places in Karnataka). But the publishers mention their sources for spellings to be “various”. c) There are 56 pages of maps of India among which 36 pages have thematic maps. The latter provides useful information for a student on various aspects of India – climate, vegetation, economy, industry etc. 2. Design and layout: a) The political maps use clear and contrasting colours for different states with 5 levels of colour intensity to denote different population levels. The physical maps use 10 contour levels for areas above sea level and 3 contour levels for those below the sea level. These make the maps clear and easy to understand. b) The region-wise physical maps of India have inset histograms and line plots of annual variation of temperature and rainfall at two key locations in the region, giving the reader a quick picture of the general climate in the region. c) The projections used for different maps have been chosen with care, depending on the region: Lambert Conical Orthomorphic – India and her neighbours, China and Mongolia Region Lambert Equal Area – Asia, South America Platte Carre/Geographic – West Asia Bonne – Asia (thematic), North and South Korea, Japan Lambert – Europe Conical with Two Standard Parallels – British Isles Azimuthal Equal Area – South-East Asia, Eurasia, North America, Africa Lambert Equal Area Azimuthal – Oceania Polar Stereographic – North and South poles Robinson – Oceans and the World (regular and thematic) Modified Gall – World (thematic) Sinusoidal – World (watersheds) This allows presenting the maps with minimal distortion of area, which in some cases are conformal (Lambert), and in some cases are a good compromise for an overall view (Robinson). 3. Quality of print and binding: a) The paper appears to be 75 gsm showing negligible bleed through, making the maps clear to read. b) The quality of printing is nice and sharp, with consistent color reproduction throughout. This stands out and becomes immediately apparent as soon as one opens the atlas. c) The paperback binding makes the atlas easy to handle. The hot melt EVA glue used for the spine is well suited for the purpose. 4. Shipping: I received the item within 2 days of ordering through regular Amazon route (non-prime), so the delivery speed was good. 5. Additional features: a) The two poster-size maps (roughly 80 cm x 54 cm) are of good print quality, and are useful to get a full picture of India or the world with good detail. b) The poster-size maps are attached to the inside back cover with a thin double sided masking tape, making it possible to pull them out carefully without damaging the paper. 6. Price: At Rs. 211 (discounted, with a cover price of Rs. 315), the atlas offers a wealth of information with good print quality for a reasonable price. Negatives: 1. Content: a) Page 6 – The last sentence in the section titled “Exploring the Universe” reads, “The Universe probably came into existence about 10-20 billion years ago”. Since this atlas was published in 2019, and measurements of the age of universe as of 2018 had found it to be 13.8 billion years (with an uncertainty of 0.02 billion years), the publishers should have reported this value instead of being unnecessarily uncertain by 10 billion years. b) Page 6 – The last sentence in the section titled “The Solar System” reads, “All the planets along with their satellites orbit the Sun in the anti-clockwise direction (if viewed from above)”. What is "above" in space? Perhaps it would’ve been better to say “… orbit the Sun in the same direction as Sun rotates about its axis”. At this point, “prograde” and “retrograde” orbits could’ve been mentioned. c) Page 7 – The introductory section titled “The Planet Earth” should have had a sentence or two explaining the meaning of equinoxes. The section also fails to inform the reader about the significance of the Arctic and Antarctic Circles. The accompanying figure can also be improved significantly by labeling the axis tilt angle and showing the brighter and darker sides of earth (facing toward and away from the sun) during different seasons. d) Since this is a student atlas for India, I feel that among the introductory sections on the universe, solar system and Earth, there should’ve been a brief history of the official surveys of Indian maps leading to the present edition, with key events and people on a timeline. e) Physical maps of union territories should’ve accompanied their political maps (pages 26-29), as has been done for other Indian regions. f) The region-wise physical maps for Asia misses out a map of the region of “Stans” (Kazakhstan, to Turkmenistan and Kyrgyzstan), which should’ve been inclu