Mostly positive: 92% of 13 reviews rate it 4★ or higher; praised for value for money and delivery & packaging; complaints about durability and noise.
Good
Value for money: “it's worth buying.”
Delivery & packaging: “Great delivery service and amazing price too.”
Ease of use: “The writing is simple yet incredibly effective, creating a constant sense of unease.”
Not so good
Durability: “The last 2 paragraphes broke me and made me sad for these characters.”
Noise: “The evil in Penpal is quiet, obsessive, patient, and intimate.”
Performance: “No gore, no cheap scares - just a slow, creeping dread that gets under your skin.”
Best for
Buyers who prioritise value for money and delivery & packaging
Watch out for
Durability: 3 reviews complain about it
92% verified purchases
U
urmila chauhan
Amazon.in
22 Oct 2017
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
So many of plot twists…
the kind of book that will make you cry so much at the end and will make you value relationships more. full of plot twists at every page. it's worth buying. Beautiful job by the author Read more Read less
K
Kanwar Anand
Amazon.in
19 Dec 2022
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
This book is cruel yet kind in its cruelty.
"We want so badly to be happy – to live the kinds of lives that we always hoped we'd live – that we give gifts to ourselves by remembering things not as they were, but as we wish they were.” -> The atmosphere is eerie, memoir like and the words of the author immediately take control of your thought system as they are written with such lucidity -> there are six chapters that happen in our protagonist's childhood, he is trying to understand what happened to him along the way. -> this book has evil in it but not in a stephen king way, it is evil in a dan auerbach way where chance of redemption is zero and mystery shall leave you baffled till the very last page -> this book is cruel but its kind in its cruelty. It left me shattered (almost) and I still feel so bad for the characters. This is what is different from reading a horror and watching one. When you watch a horror, you may or may not feel bad for the characters -> I love the protagonist and all the good characters in the book, they became a part of my own family. He tried so hard to rise above the station society set him at and it was heartening/disheartening to... LOVED THIS BOOK. Perfect 5 stars but oh man, its quite unsettling and not for everyone. I repeat this is not a Stephen King book. Nor is it a Dean Koontz. This is more psychological than both. It may be scarring in ensuring you love it. Read more Read less
Y
Yash
Amazon.in
2 Apr 2019
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
One of the creepiest books I've read
Fans of horror will love this one. It's well written and makes you want to read more and more of it. Read more Read less
K
Kindle Customer
Amazon.in
14 May 2023
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
So good!!
This was such a page turner! I felt so sorry for the kids because they had lived their lives being stalked without even knowing. So well written. Such a sad ending. Read more Read less
N
NIkita
Amazon.in
11 Jun 2026
★★★★★Format: Kindle Edition
Eerie, unsettling, and quietly disturbing in a way that lingers long after you’ve finished reading.
✍🏻 𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭’𝐬 𝐢𝐭 𝐚𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐭? When a childhood memory resurfaces, a man begins piecing together a series of strange events from his past. What starts as innocent memories of friendship, adventures in the woods, and growing up slowly reveals something far darker lurking beneath the surface. ❤️ 𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐈 𝐥𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐝 • It genuinely felt like I was reading someone’s personal diary or memories, which made everything feel disturbingly real. • The writing is simple yet incredibly effective, creating a constant sense of unease. • No gore, no cheap scares - just a slow, creeping dread that gets under your skin. • Every chapter left me thinking, 𝙒𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙛*** 𝙞𝙨 𝙜𝙤𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙤𝙣? and desperately wanting answers. • The calm, matter-of-fact narration makes the unsettling moments hit even harder. Come to think of it... what’s a book that creeped you out without relying on gore or jump scares? 💭 𝐅𝐢𝐧𝐚𝐥 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: I wouldn’t strictly call this a horror novel. It’s eerie, unsettling, and quietly disturbing in a way that lingers long after you’ve finished reading. The story unfolds through a child’s experiences, pieced together by an adult who now understands the horror of what was happening all along - and that realization makes it even more haunting. “𝘚𝘰𝘮𝘦𝘵𝘪𝘮𝘦𝘴 𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘨𝘦𝘵𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘪𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘨𝘪𝘧𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘵 𝘸𝘦 𝘨𝘪𝘷𝘦 𝘰𝘶𝘳𝘴𝘦𝘭𝘷𝘦𝘴.” Read more Read less
S
Steven S.
Amazon.in
23 Jun 2026
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
The Creepiest Book I Have Ever Read
I have read horrifying books before. I have read terrifying books, violent books, disturbing books, and stories designed to shock the reader with brutality. But Penpal by Dathan Auerbach will go down, without question, as the creepiest book I have ever read. What makes this novel so powerful is not that it relies on gore, cheap scares, or some over-the-top monster lurking in the dark. Its horror is quieter than that. Simpler. More patient. More believable. It is the kind of horror that creeps into ordinary childhood memories and corrupts them slowly, until something innocent becomes almost unbearable to look at. A school project. A walk through the woods. A missing pet. A best friend. A birthday party. Childhood places that should feel safe. These are not things that should terrify anyone. Yet by the end of this book, every one of them begins to feel like part of something much larger, darker, and more horrifying than the narrator ever understood at the time. At its surface, Penpal follows a man looking back on a series of strange and frightening memories from his childhood. These memories seem disconnected at first: moments from school, time spent with friends, unsettling incidents around his home, and ordinary childhood experiences that gradually begin to feel wrong. What makes the novel so effective is that the narrator does not fully understand what happened to him when he was young, and neither does the reader. We are forced to remember with him, question with him, and slowly piece together the truth with him. That is where the book becomes something extraordinary. Every time I thought I understood what was happening, the story revealed a deeper and more devastating layer beneath it. Details I had dismissed as odd suddenly became important. Moments that seemed innocent became disturbing. Memories that felt isolated began connecting in ways I was not prepared for. By the end, I realized I had not simply been reading a collection of creepy childhood events. I had been watching the shape of something horrifying form in the background the entire time. That is the brilliance of Penpal. It is written like memory itself. Fragmented, emotional, incomplete, and sometimes unreliable, not because the narrator is dishonest, but because he was a child when these things happened. He did not have the language to understand the danger around him. He saw pieces. Strange sounds. Odd behavior. His mother’s fear. His best friend growing distant. Moments that seemed isolated at the time. But as an adult, looking back, the narrator begins assembling the truth, and the reader is forced to assemble it with him. That experience is what made the book so effective for me. I did not simply read Penpal. I investigated it. Every chapter felt like another piece of an evidence board being pinned into place. I found myself questioning every memory, every odd line, every absence, every detail that seemed too specific to be accidental. The book trains you to pay attention. It rewards suspicion. It punishes comfort. By the final stretch, details that once seemed harmless begin to take on a completely different meaning, and that slow realization is where the true horror lives. The ending did not leave me merely scared. It left me genuinely sad. That is rare for horror. Most horror stories want to shock you, disgust you, or make you afraid to turn off the lights. This book did something worse: it made me grieve. The final revelations are not just disturbing because of what they reveal, but because of what they do to the memories that came before them. The story reaches backward and changes everything. Childhood friendship, parental protection, ordinary routines, old places, and small conversations all become stained by the terrible knowledge of what was really happening beneath the surface. That is what makes the book so sickening and so unforgettable. It is not content with being frightening in the moment. It lingers. It makes earlier chapters worse after you have finished them. It makes you reconsider every scene, every clue, every small emotional fracture. The horror was never just waiting at the end of the story. It had been there from the beginning. The antagonist, or rather the presence haunting the book, is one of the most disturbing forces I have encountered in fiction, precisely because it is not theatrical. There are no grand speeches, no supernatural explanations, no elaborate mythology to hide behind. The evil in Penpal is quiet, obsessive, patient, and intimate. It exists in the margins. It watches from a distance. It intrudes slowly. It feels terrifying because it feels possible. That is the real terror of Penpal. It is fiction, but it does not feel impossible. It feels like the kind of awful story you might hear years later from a small town, after everyone realizes the signs had been there all along. That simplicity is what makes it so horrifying. A child’s ordinary life brushes against something monstrous, and from there,
M
Marco
Amazon.in
14 May 2026
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Uno dei migliori thriller/horror che leggerete.
Ho letto prima la creepypasta, poi questo libro che ne è l'evoluzione. Mai letta una storia più avvincente e dà fiato sospeso, uno scrittore fenomenale. Consigliatissimo. Read more Read less
A
AA
Amazon.in
21 Aug 2025
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
A masterclass in disappointment
I bought Penpal after scrolling through all those glowing 5-star reviews at the top. People called it “haunting,” “unforgettable,” even a “game-changer.” Naturally, I thought I was about to read something groundbreaking. Spoiler: the only thing groundbreaking here is how quickly it broke my patience.I finished Penpal in 2 hours and 30 minutes, and honestly, I wish I could get that time back. This book is basically one big spoiler after another, scattered through pages like confetti, so by the time you reach the end there’s nothing left to be surprised about. And speaking of the end—what end? There’s no proper conclusion, no big reveal, no “oh my god” moment that makes you sit back in shock. Just a flat, anticlimactic fizzle that leaves you wondering why you even bothered. It promises horror and suspense, but delivers confusion and disappointment. If you enjoy wasting money and time, go ahead and buy this. Otherwise, do yourself a favor and skip it. Read more Read less
B
Beatriz Araujo Sardenberg
Amazon.in
19 Mar 2025
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
Different types of horror - check if it fits what you like. I liked it!
Great book, keeps the angst level high all throughout. Very well written. To me particularly, I find the horror in the anxiety of the unknown, whereas when things are more gore or just very in your face horror (be it because of monsters, or very described horror scenes and villains etc) I think it loses a bit its capacity to create horror and angst in the reader. So, without giving details, there is a part of the book where I find that, for me, it loses its magic a bit. I thought of giving it 4 for that, but after having read it in a while, I can look back and see it is still one of the best horror books, if not the best one, I have ever read. I do recomend it! Read more Read less
M
MaggieVeggie
Amazon.in
23 Aug 2026
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
its awesome
You guys have to buy this its so worth it the plot is so good can't believe it Read more Read less
H
hiba
Amazon.in
4 Jun 2023
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
REALISTIC HORROR AT IT'S BEST
this was such an interesting read. One of the best horror books I have ever read. I felt every scene, every emotion in this. The horror scenes got me scared to look out of my window at night. This book is really thought out and makes sense once you hit the ending. And what an ENDING, I was horrified, creeped out but also devastated. I cried . No I sobbed. The last 2 paragraphes broke me and made me sad for these characters. It's been a month since I finished it but my mind keep going back to it. It's an amazing book and I highly recommend it. Read more Read less
P
PIYALI
Amazon.in
24 Jul 2023
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Kindle Edition
An Unsettling Horror Story
A really effective one. I would give it 4.5 stars. Reading the book is a chilling experience even if the ending is a bit trite. Read more Read less
S
SP
Amazon.in
9 Apr 2025
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
A must read and a steal at this price
Finished the book in one day! Couldn’t put it down. Great delivery service and amazing price too. Read more Read less