A sharp one
Amazon.in18 Aug 2015
A classic marred by a disgusting mastering.
It is shocking how one of the greatest films to have ever come out of India is treated in the country of origin! What is ironic is that the film does have a better version available - all the way from France. Yes, this is absolutely true. French studio Carlotta Films released what has become the definitive home version is still available albeit at inflated prices because it is simply the best way to watch this masterpiece at this time. The French DVD release comes as a twin DVD pack consisting of the film "Pyaasa" along with it. The DVD has the documentary "In Search of Guru Dutt" as an extra feature. The French version surprisingly from a clear and pristine print, and the audio in a Dolby Digital Mono mix. This means that the French version, at present, the only way to see the film as it was intended, at least nearly so. The presentation is accurate and the picture quality is the best yet. The French version is so easy on the eye that the Ultra version would remind you of hell. The Ultra DVD cover proudly claims to have digitally enhanced the audio to 5.1. The sound is NOT 5.1 Surround but a poor mono presentation. In short, AVOID the desi Ultra dvd and do yourself a favour and find the French release from Carlotta Films and buy that one instead. You will pay more but then you will get more. 'Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam' is a film that deserves the highest praise and the best presentation on dvd or blu-ray. It is shameful that the French treat our films better than we do. Read more Read less














