Anil Misra
Amazon.in9 Dec 2021
Useful Book But Far Too Lengthy
The author is a former Foreign Secretary to the Government of India in about 2000 and thus was actively involved in India-China dialogues. The book however does not however deal with her time as Foreign Secretary or any post 1962 developments. To be fair the author makes it clear that the book deals with developments till 1962 and no further. This book thus does not offer insights into the more recent India-China developments. The author however is a practitioner-diplomat not a scholar compiling material for posterity. The purpose of the book therefore unclear. The author accepts that she is not treading new ground: the material in the book is already in the public domain but dispersed. She can thus be thanked for collating the available material in one book. Possibly a great help to future students working on their MA theses. The author states in the "Introduction" that the book is intended for the younger generation, the that today has no memory of the events of 1962. The book however is far too long winded for the younger generation or for any lay reader. It follows a linear time based narrative. Nothing much happens in most of the middle chapters: endless repetitions of the Indian and Chinese positions. I read the first few chapter of the book, then got bored because the material was repetitive. I then jumped to Chapter 15 which I found to be the most interesting of the chapters that I read. Terrible reading for an Indian actually: by mid 1962 the Indian leadership had realised that a war was around the corner. It knew by then that it couldn't win a war with China and desperately sought a face saving solution. Sadly the leadership had by then painted itself into a corner with its tough public posturing. Whatever China offered was politically not good enough. India thus walked into a most humiliating defeat. The "Coda" to the book is possibly the most interesting part of the book. The author asks the question: that even with the benefit of hindsight what are the things that we could have done differently in 1962. Since the author has no answer to offer, she quickly applies the gloss and moves on to generalities. I hope that the present Indian leadership does have answers to the "China" question. It would be an unfathomable tragedy if, in similar circumstances, we are again found short. To sum up up, the chapters 3 to 14 of the book could have been compressed into two or at best three chapters. The "Coda" needs to answer the question raised, vague generalities are no answer 60 years after the event. I hope the author will give these suggestions thought in the next edition of the book. To conclude, at the beginning of the book the author takes a dig at Mr. Nehru. She quotes Isaiah Berlin to describe Mr. Nehru as someone who knew many things but found it difficult to deduce the core meaning of any one of them, fully. I think I can, without being unkind, say the same about the author too. Read more Read less













