M De Sarkar
Amazon.in8 Oct 2019
A charming edition of an everlasting tale. A charming edition of an everlasting tale.
If your search for a decent edition of 'The Hobbit' has brought you here then possibly there are two conclusions one could arrive at about you, the Reader. Firstly, you are a hardback aficionado, and second, illustrations do matter to you. This brings us directly to the important question. Why go for this particular edition when the version illustrated by Alan Lee(Houghton Mifflin Harcourt; 114th edition) is the Holy grail against which any illustrated edition of 'The Hobbit' will always be weighed? Being in possession of both the editions, I think this is more of an apples to oranges comparison. The illustrations in the Alan Lee version are serious and atmospheric works of art that look like something an Art Museum might have granted rights to the publisher to use. The images in this edition have more of a cartoonish sort of feel which complement the overall trip-happy vibe in 'The Hobbit'. But I just cannot imagine fun artwork of this sort making its appearance in an edition of LOTR anytime soon. That said, I would rate this edition an overall five star with impeccable binding and print quality. As for the subject matter, I do not think my two cents will add or take away anything from the consensus on the greatness of Tolkien's literary megaliths. I shall end my review with a side by side pictorial analysis of the versions illustrated by Alan Lee and Jemima Catlin (the last four full page spreads being from the Alan Lee edition). Illustrations are from the introductory scene of Thorin and Co., the troll encounter episode, Bilbo's meeting with Gollum in the Misty Mountains and Smaug with his treasure horde in Lonely Mountain. I personally love Lee's style, though there are many who will be biased towards Catlin's lighthearted artwork. Read more Read less









