In my mind Cicero is one of the world's greatest political thinkers. His views on mixed constitution and the importance of maintaining a high moral standard among the citizens and rulers of a state have moved me more than any other. Where most other philosophers are either more concerned with pure idealism or attempt to be overly realistic, Cicero walks the fine line between. He was a moral philosopher, and so he is concerned more with educating the minds of his readers than to persuade them of any one way of thinking. KNOWING what is best isn't enough, if you don't know WHY. In The Republic, the three possible constitutions (rule of the one, rule of the few, and rule of the many) are discussed in the same style as Plato's dialogues. The good of all three is weighed against the evil, and the entire nature of politics is touched upon in this, sadly fragmented, discussion. In true Socratic dialectic style the ideal becomes the converged ideal, the mixed constitution which ensures the fairness of democracy, the righteousness of aristocracy, and the efficiency of the monarchy, while restraining the subverted forms of either through the sound structure of the states institutions. The Laws are not a draft of actual laws but a philosophical letter meant for his son, which addresses the nature of laws and law making. It even touches upon the subject of equality which he saw as a state of being between individuals rather than something which could ever hope to be imposed by any institution Cicero's view were radical in his own time and although they never dominated either philosophy or politics, they have influenced Western civilization for more than 2000 years. This book should be read by anyone wanting to enter into politics or even just discuss politics on a leisurely level. Read more Read less
T
Terry Kauffman
Amazon.in
11 Apr 2026
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Good product
For the young and those that think we are so enlightened, this is a book that dives deep into the types of discussions that were had thousands of years ago. It's not for the average reader and you need to have a curiosity about Plato, Socrates and others to appreciate the dialogue. It's different than how we speak so be patient with yourself as you educate yourself. Read more Read less
P
Paul Krause
Amazon.in
9 Feb 2019
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
The Origins of Natural Law
Cicero is the most important of the Roman philosophers; a Roman Platonist and Stoic, he is responsible for attempting to synthesize strands of Platonic and Stoic thought into a coherent body of mostly political philosophy. It may not be farfetched to assert that Cicero is the first synthetic political philosopher and the second systematic political philosopher in the Western tradition after Plato. The origins of classical natural law and right are contained in the books of the Laws, of which the first book is the most important and influential. Those with a solid grounding in Catholic natural law tradition, from Augustine to Aquinas and beyond, may find resonances and stumble upon why Cicero—thought a pagan—was generally held in high regard by Catholics. (His Latin prose is just as remarkable as his thought.) There are a few things to know about Cicero in relationship to his larger philosophical anthropology which is important when reading the Laws. He was, like Plato and Aristotle, a monotheist. He found “pagan” religion as useful only insofar that it provided stability and heritage, but he largely found the actual teachings of pagan cults to be insufficient in comparison to the “true God” of Reason; that said, he never advocated the abolition of the Roman pantheon because he knew better than to offend the plebeians who can easily be riled up into a frenzy. Cicero’s humanism and natural law theory is tied to his monotheism (or at least to his idea of the highest God being the God of Reason) and understanding – much like in Catholicism – that humans are sharers in the divine nature through the gift of reason. Hence, Cicero’s humanism is rooted in the primacy of Logos – or Reason – which is a gift of divinity and makes us like God. For Cicero, as per Natural Law theory, what constitutes natural law is the governing force behind human action. While happiness, or ontological flourishing, is the telos to human existence in Cicero’s mind, what allows us to reach this end is reason itself. As Cicero, through the character “Marcus” in the Laws states, “There is no topic which brings out so clearly what nature has bestowed on man, how many excellent things the human mind contains…what sort of factor unites humans and what natural fellowship exists between them.” This is the beginning of Cicero’s exploration into natural law, the divine gift of reason, and why reason is what permits humans to march toward excellence. Accordingly, the natural law in Cicero is what unites humanity together in common spirit. This common spirit is tied to want for wisdom and knowledge, which is principally manifested through the common gift of reasoning which is implanted into all persons. Furthermore, the natural law calls humanity together through justice and happiness. The natural law, and reason, is communitarian in nature and aims at communitarian virtue: intimate and deep participation with others in a common project called the homeland, or fatherland. This is generally remembered as the “classical natural law” theory in which natural law can be sufficiently understood by reason and that, in this understanding of the natural law – which is an embrace of one’s nature – the end to our existence (happiness) can become manifested. Cicero recognizes the same claim made in Judaism and Christianity, through Genesis, concerning what Abrahamic religion calls imago Dei, or the image of God. Christianity developed – through Augustine – the idea of the “substantive view” of the imago Dei. This is the belief that the soul is the mind and that this soul/mind has the imparted gift of grace called logos (reason) which makes us, literally by our very composition, sharers in the divine image. For Cicero, human reason is a gift from God. As he writes, “There is nothing better than reason, and reason is present in both man and God, there is a primordial partnership in reason between man and God.” And as he also states, “In debates on the nature of man it is usually maintained, doubtless correctly, that in the course of the continuous circuits and revolutions of the heavens the right moment arrived for sowing the human race, that after being scattered and sown in the earth it was furthered endowed with the divine gift of mind; that whereas men derived the other elements in their make-up from their mortal nature—elements which are fragile and transitory—their mind was implanted in them by God.” According to Cicero, then, the means by which we come to know ourselves, and the natural law, is through right reason, “But those who share also share right reason, and since that is law, we men must also be thought of as partners with [Divinity] in the laws.” The primary impetus of Cicero’s natural law and right reasoning to coming to know the natural law is moral. The law is moral and coming to know the law through right reasoning is what permits humans to attain moral excellence (arête), and this is what permits the growth into virtue and the
C
Christian Rosello Fjell-Weiseth
Amazon.in
27 May 2012
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
The book of enlightened statecraft
This book is highly recommended to everyone that has intellectually evolved past the marxist, socialist, capitalist or classical liberal theories and has a deep understanding of not just political theory, but more importantly empirical facts regarding the consequenes of these theories when they are institutionalized. This is not a beginners book, but is recommended to anyone having read Schumpeter, John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, Rousseau, Karl Marx, Milton Friedman, John Stuart Mill, Platon, Aristotle, Gadamer, Kant and Machiavelli. The reason for this is because this book does not embrace radical ideas suited for young minds, but reflecting ideas suited for a sophisticated mature mind. I will not give any examples to the arguments and philosophy of Cicero as I want other readers to experience them for themselves, as they are revelations. The book is highly entertaining to read as it is enlightening, it is written as a screenplay of a group of friends spending the summer holiday at the great Scipio Africanus summer estate in the suburbs of Rome discussing the best form of society, and deals with themes from Justice, Traditions, Religion, Power, distribution of Capital, wellfare, trade and war. This book is for the mature mind as it is built on empirical facts of history rather than political wishfull thinking of utopias. This book provides a blueprint for the most stable society, where imperfect human beings can coexist in prosperity and justice without the need for revolutions or depressions. Read more Read less
C
Christopher R. Travers
Amazon.in
27 Oct 2009
★★★★★Verified purchase
Good translation of important works
I enjoyed this translation and found it to be quite accessible. The two works go together to discuss the ideal state through a reasonably sophisticated approach though one which is quite trapped by views of Roman superiority. After all, Cicero begins by extolling the virtues of patriotism so we shouldn't be surprised if his ideal state looks exactly like his own state. However, the approach taken by Cicero is rather interesting. Rather than emphasizing a specific structure, he seems to emphasize ongoing synthesis of elements of different structures, emphasizing the importance of what might later be thought to be a "social contract theory of government." Often I think in many areas of political discourse returning to this basic level would be helpful even in our modern age. The second work builds upon this by offering a system of laws for the ideal republic. This helps to clarify Cicero's thinking a great deal by offering more concrete examples of how the Republic should be formed. The introduction and end notes add a great deal to this edition. Anyone interested in theory of government, Roman studies, or Cicero in general, should read this book. Highly recommended. Read more Read less