Abraham Joseph
Amazon.in2 Nov 2017
one of Agatha's wonderful British mysteries set at a grand English country house
The Secret of Chimneys is, at first glance, one of Agatha's wonderful British mysteries set at a grand English country house, and I do love the setting--there are even secret passages! However, the mystery plays second-fiddle to the sort of self-conscious "adventure" plot that I disliked in The Secret Adversary. It is both good and bad that the novel is specific to the era between the World Wars--on the one hand, it is more political and topical than many of her novels, which gives it a period flavor, but on the other hand this means it is not "timeless" like some of her very best work which transcends time and locale despite the wealth of wonderful details about English life. There are just too many spies and secret identities for me to suspend my disbelief here! Some of it is intentionally humorous/satirical, but the really god-awful pun related to the clue in the secret passage seemed unworthy of Agatha, and the final twist at the end--though unexpected--made me groan instead of my usual shocked delight. I do like some of the characters, esp the fascinating heroine (Virginia Revel) and good ol' Superintenent Battle of the Yard, but this was not one of my favorites Read more Read less

