Mostly positive: 83% of 12 reviews rate it 4★ or higher; praised for delivery & packaging and ease of use; complaints about build quality.
Good
Delivery & packaging: “After all, not all movies elicit brilliant responses and become box office hits.”
Ease of use: “bit disjointed...easy to follow could be a nice film for international market ...?”
Not so good
Build quality: “In my opinion, this book is a solid introduction to the subject, but not a fleshed out exploration.”
Best for
Buyers who prioritise delivery & packaging and ease of use
Watch out for
Build quality: 2 reviews complain about it
100% verified purchases
A
Ayusman
Amazon.in
5 Dec 2021
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Loveable
This is a scholarly work. But it does not bore one with jargons. The style is lucid and entertaining. It seeks to answer why we, the homo sapiens, go on loving stories. It explores the uses, and misuses, of stories. The writer's familiarity with different branches of knowledge enables him to present a cogent argument. I consider it a must read for all students and professors of literature. Read more Read less
D
Dixita Patel
Amazon.in
8 Oct 2012
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Hardcover
Engaging book, but acts as an introduction to the topic
Jonathan Gottschall looks into how and why humans are pulled to stories, making various cases and presenting interesting theories along the way. In my opinion, this book is a solid introduction to the subject, but not a fleshed out exploration. In this review, I would like to go through the most engaging parts for me and why I have come to certain conclusions or opinions. Neverland never leaves us The book begins by setting up the stage for this fascinating topic. It starts guiding us through various ideas (and even a test) to prove how bewitching stories can be. Gottschall uses the idea of Neverland throughout the book and it is mentioned in the first chapter. He starts by noting that children love spending time creating stories and enacting them. Then, he writes, "We may leave the nursery, with its toy trucks and dress-up clothes, but we never stop pretending. We just change how we do it. Novels, dreams, films, and fantasies are provinces of Neverland." He points out that humans never stop their involvement with stories. This seems quite true since there are many executives and producers that use story to move their customers and audiences. From the old ages where storytelling was mainly word-of-mouth to now where storytelling takes form in TV, movies, and even video games, stories have attracted us and I think they always will. Why does Neverland never leave us? The true question is why story has not been eliminated from human life through evolution. Basically, there has to be some sort of purpose for story. Otherwise, it would not have pursued to stay with us for so long. Some people think that fiction is used for a lot of things, like exercising the mind, passing down experiences, or forming a social glue among people. However, what if the alternative is considered? In my opinion, Gotschall introduces one of the most interesting theories here. Perhaps fiction is for nothing at all. It serves no purpose. At first, I thought this was a very poor argument to make. After all, story is all around us. If it was for nothing, wouldn't it have been eliminated through evolution, like mentioned before? Then, he makes his case, "Story may educate us, deepen us, and give us joy. Story may be one of the things that makes its most worthwhile to be human. But that doesn't mean story has a biological purpose." Although it seemed hard to believe (and I didn't want to think all my hours reading books were wasteful), it opened my mind. Maybe stories are for the sole purpose of enjoyment. We do many things that we have no value or need for, so maybe story is one of them. Not just empathy, but sympathy Humans cannot have stories if there is no conflict. If there is a story with no problems or interesting scenarios, the story is not at all engaging. The story does not elicit a response. Here, Gottschall finally started to bring in some science. As a current student in an introductory neuroscience class, I had been waiting for a neurological and scientific inquiry into why stories charm and move us. In one case, scientists used fMRI machines to monitor audience reaction. While watching the movie The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly, it was discovered that "When Eastwood was angry, the viewer's brains looked angry, too. When the scene was sad, the viewers' brains also looked sad." With brain scanning, scientists were able to see that mirror neurons started firing in the brain. This caused the audience to have real, strong emotional responses that coincided with the story being told. They would not just empathize with the characters, but sympathize with them. However, this exploration into mirror neurons was short. There is not much more that Gottschall included, not that there needed to be any more with the point he was making. Still, I would have liked a little more meat, a little more scientific background into this topic. Also, there are some cases where audiences react more strongly to one scenario than another. It would have been great to learn the reasoning behind this. After all, not all movies elicit brilliant responses and become box office hits. Jouvet's Cats It is really strange to think about dreams, how they occur, why they occur, what causes one dream compared to another, etc. Gottschall explains some well known theories, such as one from Freud and the random activation theory (RAT). Jouvet's cats were intriguing to read about (again, my bias towards neuroscience coming into play). Jouvet severed the connection in the brain stem that signaled for paralysis in sleep in a few cats. During sleep, the cats would experience many scenarios of capturing prey or avoiding predators. Apparently, the dream world is filled with trouble. Again, there seems to be no story without conflict and since dreams are riddled with stories, they are riddled with conflict. Now that I think back to my own dreams (or those that I remember), it seems like they are all filled with trouble, sadness, or some sort of mission to resolve a dilemma. Pe
A
Ashwin Vikraman
Amazon.in
20 Jun 2019
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Waste of money
Don't buy this book I read the first page itself I stopped reading this book please don't waste your money this is book is very overrated Read more Read less
A
Alice
Amazon.in
28 Oct 2026
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Engaging, accessible and fascinating
Brilliantly written, engaging and fascinating. This is my favourite book for understanding why humans love and need story. As a non-academic, it is accessible and the references are a goldmine for further reading. Read more Read less
E
Eleonora M.
Amazon.in
23 Aug 2017
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
ottimo libro per capire come funziona l'essere umano
Ritengo la lettura di questo libro fondamentale per capire l'importanza delle storie e del gioco per l'essere umano. Spiegazioni molto soddisfacenti su come funzioniamo! Read more Read less
N
niyas
Amazon.in
10 Jul 2019
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Cheated
The book is of very low quality.. it looks like a pirated copy.. feel angry and sad Read more Read less
N
Nilam Doctor
Amazon.in
19 Mar 2019
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Must read
Love it Read more Read less
A
Amazon Customer
Amazon.in
6 Mar 2017
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Five Stars
good Read more Read less
A
Alexandre Coutinho
Amazon.in
6 Nov 2024
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
Indispensável para escritores e jornalistas
Uma ferramenta para compreender melhor a importância das narrativas na história do homem. Read more Read less
S
sarita
Amazon.in
13 Sept 2013
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
slice of female indian culture
nice quick read....liked the lead female... bit disjointed...easy to follow could be a nice film for international market ...? enjoyed Read more Read less
C
ch_ve
Amazon.in
31 Aug 2018
★★★★★Verified purchase
Tratado
De manera breve y sencilla profundiza en aspectos centrales de la antropología, es una gran perspectiva de lo que nos hace humanos. Read more Read less
C
Cuau
Amazon.in
7 Mar 2024
★★★★★Verified purchaseFormat: Paperback
One of my favourite books ever
Intensely entertaining, mind blowing, makes you question everything. Full of revealing research, pop culture references and good storytelling overall! Read more Read less