nilina
Amazon.in24 Aug 2023
An enjoyable sweeping saga An enjoyable sweeping saga
To start with, I thoroughly enjoyed reading The covenant of water, didn't find it boring, difficult to read, or ever wish it would get over, for whatever reason. Many a time when I holiday or travel with a book, I find that my reading experience gets affected. But with this one, I travelled, met long lost cousins, old friends, hordes of relatives and finally spent a week with my mum, all while inhabiting the world of 'Parambil', in parallel. It held me in its warm embrace right through its 720 pages. This is not usual. So I believe it's a great book. Dr. Verghese is a wonderful storyteller and he's managed to come out with this piece that has an almost meditative quality to it. Digging into what may have brought on that quality, two things strike me. One is his compassion with his characters. There's not a single despicable character in there. The other is a distinct thread of hope that runs right through the book. Even while life takes unexpected and harsh turns, somewhere deep down, one knows that they will be fine. There's an underlying stoic acceptance of every situation there, that seems to give us this comfort. I could see the author as a person who had come to terms with life, who had understood the human condition for what it is. This is one of the things that stood out for me about this book. The reason I think it's an important book is that, for those who haven't lived in Kerala, and who are unfamiliar with the Syrian Christian ethos, it's a wonderful world that he creates. And when he narrates it in the background of that period in the history of Kerala with the events that shaped the state into what it is today, it takes on a different proportion altogether. The fact that he doesn't hurry the reader through it, makes it that much more effective. One has the luxury of taking it all in slowly. It's also an extremely accessible book with its simple prose. To summarise, a couple of points I found negative about the book: It does not challenge the reader in any way. It feels more like a fable rather than a realistic portrayal of life. It's not to say that a realistic portrayal of life is somehow superior to a fable. But I get the impression that the author didn't mean it to be a fable. It's perhaps not fair to compare books, esp in different languages, but I'm tempted to do that because not only do these two belong to the same genre, they are both set in the Kerala of more or less the same period although they tell different stories. When I reflected on why the contemporary Malayalam author Subhash Chandran's "Manushyanu oru aamukham" that came out a couple of years ago made a more lasting impact on me, I realise that it was more nuanced, more raw and realistic, and the characters truer to their identities. The book itself was much more layered, with rich insights into human psychology. But again, for the world at large, access to that book is limited. Even though there is a translation (A preface to man) for which the translator even won an award, it is not a particularly translatable book. That's what I gathered from someone who read the translation. From that perspective, I can see "The Covenant of water" going places, and rightly so. Read more Read less









